Review: The Girl From The Resistance by Imogen Matthews*

*I received a copy of this book in eBook format via NetGalley in return for this review. All reviews published on Yours, Chloe are completely honest and my own, and are in now way influenced by the gifting opportunity.

Title: The Girl From The Resistance
Author: Imogen Matthews
Genre: Historical Fiction

Trigger warnings:  War, Antisemitism, Guns, Parent Alcoholism

Rating: 

1941, Nazi-occupied Holland. Trudi can hear the muffled sobs of two heartbroken little girls as they peer wide-eyed from their hiding place behind the bookcase. Rosy and Louisa’s parents have been dragged away by soldiers. Now Trudi is the only one who can keep them safe…

When Nazis break down the front door of eighteen-year-old Trudi’s home and seize the Jewish couple hiding in her attic, she’s devastated, and is suddenly solely responsible for their two innocent children. The whispered rumours about the resistance are her only hope. A man called Frans and his cousin Piet risk their lives every day, helping scared and abandoned Jewish children escape into the countryside. Under the cover of night she races to beg for their help.

When the girls are offered a safe house, Trudi is relieved. But with soldiers on every corner of the cobbled streets, getting there will be extremely dangerous… she must dress up in a German nurse’s uniform and convince anyone who asks that she is transporting two children to hospital.

Trudi will have to give up everything to protect Rosy and Louisa. She will have to lie to her friends and family, and learn to fire a weapon that could take someone’s life. The only consolation is Piet’s dark eyes and handsome face as he stands beside her helping to plan her next steps.

But Trudi suspects someone close to her told the Nazis about the hiding place in the attic, and they’ll stop at nothing to make sure the girls do not escape…

The Girl From The Resistance is the first instalment of the new ‘The Dutch Girls’ series from author Imogen Matthews. It is an inspiring story about the bravery of the Dutch resistance putting their lives at risk to help others escape Nazi persecution.

The narrative follows Trudi as she joins the resistance and starts to complete a range of different jobs for them. Some of the chapters were slower paced as Trudi takes on some of the more day-to-day resistance work such as messenger work but I enjoyed this aspect as it showcased how important even the more mundane and less risky tasks were to contributing to the resistance efforts. The second half of the novel is more fast-paced and action-packed and had me on the edge of my seat. The story flowed well overall and it was an easy read, easy to finish in just a single sitting.

I was excited to see that this was the start of a new series and would be interested to see if the books would be standalone stories or if we’d see a return to the stories of Trudi or one of the other characters featured in The Girl From The Resistance. I’d be particularly keen to return to Rosy and Louisa’s story as they were fantastic characters.

I did struggle to warm to Trudi as a protagonist which was a shame. Her naivety and willingness to divulge the secrets of her resistance work to people she had only just met and didn’t know if she could trust was frustrating to say the least. We did see good character development from her however as she completed more work for the resistance and grew in confidence and maturity.

My overall feeling is that the story would have been stronger if everything had been explored in more depth. We’re introduced to many characters but find out very little about them. For example, Piet, who plays a large role in the plot, is introduced and it’s clear that Trudi has an initial attraction to him but we’re not given any context as to why as we learn very little about him.

Overall, The Girl From The Resistance is an enjoyable and easy to read historical fiction novel and the start of a potentially exciting new series. The Dutch resistance is a fascinating aspect of World War Two history and I look forward to seeing where Imogen Matthews takes the rest of her series.

Review: The Girl Who Escaped by Angela Petch*

 *I received a copy of this book in eBook format via NetGalley in return for this review. All reviews published on Yours, Chloe are completely honest and my own, and are in now way influenced by the gifting opportunity.

Title: The Girl Who Escaped
Author: Angela Petch
Genre: Historical Fiction

Trigger warnings:  War, Antisemitism, Guns, Suicide, Torture, Murder

Rating: 

Italy, 1940. The girl sobs and rages as her father tells her the terrible news. “Italy is entering the war alongside Germany. Jews are to be arrested and sent to camps. We have to be ready.”

As fascists march across the cobbled piazzas and past the towered buildings of her beloved home city, twenty-year-old Devora’s worst fears come true. Along with her Jewish parents and twin little brothers they are torn away from everything they love and sent to an internment camp huddled in the mountains. Her father promises this war will not last long…

When they are offered a miraculous chance of escape by her childhood friend Luigi, who risks everything to smuggle vital information into the camp, the family clambers under barbed wire and races for the border. But Devora is forced to make a devastating choice between saving a stranger’s life and joining her parents. As shots fire in the moonless night, the family is separated.

Haunted by the question of whether they are dead or alive, all Devora can do for their future is throw herself into helping Luigi in the Italian resistenza in the fight for liberty. But posing as a maid for a German commander to gather secret intelligence, Devora is sure she sees her friend one night, in a Nazi uniform…

Is Devora in more danger than ever? And will her family ever be reunited – or will the war tear them apart?

The Girl Who Escaped is the latest captivating historical fiction novel from author Angela Petch. It is an emotional roller-coaster of a story which takes the reader through a journey from truly heartbreaking moments to more heartwarming moments and I was hooked from the very first page.

I have to applaud Angela Petch for how well she has clearly researched this story. It meant that the history just seeped through the page. I particularly enjoyed the use of Italian phrases where appropriate throughout the narrative as this really supported the story to feel authentic to the setting.

We have a really strong courageous female protagonist in Devora. Her character growth throughout the progression of the story, based on her wartime experiences, was extremely well written. I also found the exploration of Devora’s questioning of her faith to be a really interesting aspect of the story. We are also given a few chapters from her childhood friend Enrico’s perspective and, whilst it did add an interesting angle to the story, I found him to be a thoroughly unlikeable character which made Devora’s infatuation with him very hard to understand. On the other side of the likeability scale was another childhood friend Luigi who was a wonderfully written character I fell in love with almost instantly. I loved the chapters exploring his story and found them to compliment the chapters focusing on Devora’s story well. The resistance work Luigi did through his government job registering births and deaths and falsifying records to protect people was absolutely fascinating so it made it amazing to read that this character was inspired by the grandfather of the author’s husband and his courageous actions as a partisan during the war.  I would have liked to have seen a little more exploration of Sabrina’s character and experiences. The prologue sets up the story about the four teenagers and whilst we learn lots about Devora, Luigi and Enrico, we see very little from Sabrina and I do think this was a shame as the choices she made during the German occupation could have added an interesting angle to the story if explored in further depth.

The narrative also features a large collection of characters in minor supporting roles, such as those living in the internment camp with Devora, the partisans and other Italians supporting the resistance effort. Angela Petch has a magical and rare ability to craft these supporting characters in a way which gives such depth to their characters and makes them come alive on the page, even those who play minor roles in the overall plot.

Two supporting characters whose story was particularly interesting was Anna Maria and the German soldier she befriends. Whilst avoiding spoilers, I would have liked their story to have been explored in a little more depth.

The Girl Who Escaped pays wonderful homage to the Italians who were so courageous during the Second World War, saving the lives of so many Jewish Italians. As noted in the Author’s Note, approximately 80% of Jews in Italy survived the war whereas 80% of Jews in the rest of occupied Europe were murdered. Despite being an avid World War Two historical fiction reader with a real passion for wartime history, this was something I previously wasn’t aware of and it was truly fascinating.

Overall, The Girl Who Escaped is a really powerful piece of historical fiction which I would highly recommend for fans of historical fiction set during the Second World War. This was my first time reading anything by Angela Petch but it was an incredible introduction to her work and I can’t wait to read more from her.

TEMPLATE DESIGNED BY PRETTYWILDTHINGS